Main | カスパル代表 近藤美津枝氏の発言から表現の自由を考える② »

カスパル代表 近藤美津枝氏の発言から表現の自由を考える①

大谷昭弘氏の奈良少女誘拐殺人事件に関する「オタク犯人呼ばわり発言」問題

http://homepage2.nifty.com/otani-office/nikkan/n050104.html
http://homepage2.nifty.com/otani-office/nikkan/n041123.html

が少し、沈静化に向かったかと思いきや、今度は、NPO法人「カスパル」の近藤美津枝氏が「少女をイラストで描いたポルノ雑誌やアダルトゲームソフトの製造、販売の法的規制が必要だ。」と大声で主張をし始めています。

(記事の全文)
http://mytown.asahi.com/osaka/news01.asp?kiji=1108

極めて憂慮すべき状況だと考えますので、僕のBlogの初書き込みとします。

まず、最初に山口の立場をはっきりしておきますが、私は、特定個人の具体的な権利ないし利益を侵害しない限り、表現の自由を制約することは許されないと考えています。

したがいまして、いわゆる「ポルノグラフィー」については勿論、いわゆる「差別的な表現」ないし「ヘイトスピーチ」についても特定の個人に向けられたものではない限り、規制することについては、反対します。

なお、いわゆる「児童ポルノ」については、実在の児童を被写体とした実写ポルノについては、当該児童の性的な自己決定権などの権利を侵害するため、取り締まりもやむを得ないと考えていますが、アニメ、マンガ、文字表現などによる性表現については、例え、児童との性行為をテーマとしたものについても、規制を及ぼすことには否定的な立場を取っています。

その理由は、ぎりぎり煮詰めれば、以下の3つに纏められます。

(1)表現を抹殺したところで現実はなくなりません。性表現や差別的な表現などがこの社会において流通しているということそれ自体が、消すことも変えることもできない現実です。表現行為を抹殺することは、後世の人々が、その時代について、評価することを妨げる行為であり、歴史を捏造することに他なりません。

(2)そもそも表現規制を主張する者達が特定の表現物の廃棄を要求するのは、それに接する機会を得られたからです。表現に接することが出来なければ、批判すべきかどうか、判断できないはずであり、自分では読んだものを、他人には読ませないよう要求するのは、公正さを欠く態度であると言わざるを得ません。

(3)表現規制を主張するということは、「極めて傲慢」あるいは「選民的」な姿勢であると思います。
   それは、以下の2つの理由によります。

 ア 当の表現に接しなければ、表現の内容についての判断はできないし、表現規制を主張する者達の主張も検証できないからです。表現規制を主張する者達は、「自らの主張は絶対に正しいのであるから、検証不能である」と宣言しているのであり、そこには、謙虚さのかけらも見当たりません。特に規制の主体が権力である場合には、「権力に対する市民のチェック」という民主制の根本原理が奪われることになり、立憲民主主義の基本に反します。

 イ 表現の受け止め方、評価の仕方は、人それぞれの筈です。それを批判的、あるいは、比喩的に受け止め、評価することも出来るのです。しかしながら、表現規制を主張する者達は、自分達以外の表現受容者は、出版社や著者の意図どおりに、あるいは、自分達が受け止めるとおりに、表現行為を受け止めるであろうと決め付けています。
   ある表現をどう受け止めるかは、各個人の自由に任されるべきであり、権力あるいはそれ以外の者が代わって判断することは出来ない筈です。

|

Main | カスパル代表 近藤美津枝氏の発言から表現の自由を考える② »

Comments

I am really enjoying the theme/design of your weblog. Do you ever run into any internet browser compatibility issues? A few of my blog audience have complained about my website not operating correctly in Explorer but looks great in Opera. Do you have any recommendations to help fix this issue?

Posted by: bed bath and beyond printable coupon | July 12, 2011 at 12:11 PM

xbox 360 emulator for pc clash of clans cheats no

Posted by: xbox 360 emulator v3.2.6.rar | February 20, 2014 at 04:36 AM

Kim kardashian full free sex tape, am going to a person will advice me acquire my rubberized ducky?

Posted by: http://kardashian36h.com | March 12, 2014 at 06:25 PM

Are able to activities achieve a few a lot better as See kim kardashian tape online?

Posted by: kim kardashian tape tube | March 13, 2014 at 10:45 AM

Full length kim kardashian sex tape accompanied by because affliction am obliged to be a difficult endeavor.

Posted by: http://kardashianexposed.net | March 13, 2014 at 11:27 PM

My phrase flow is pleasurable Lindsay lohan free full streaming sex tape.

Posted by: lindsay lohan sex tape free download avi torrent | March 18, 2014 at 07:28 PM

Pictures of salma hayek nude all of this am amazingly exciting again again after it arrived accessible, it already been acknowledged as a person's 10 commandments.

Posted by: http://celebtapez.info/salma-hayek-nude-15915 | March 25, 2014 at 09:00 AM

Saved as a favorite, I like your blog!

Posted by: kim Kardashian Nude | January 21, 2015 at 09:30 AM

My partner and I stumbled over here coming from a different web address and thought I might as well check things out. I like what I see so now i am following you. Look forward to going over your web page for a second time.

Posted by: kim kardashian sex tape | June 19, 2015 at 08:32 PM

My partner and I stumbled over here different website and thought I might check things out. I like what I see so now i am following you. Look forward to checking out your web page repeatedly.

Posted by: DanialZKroemer | July 27, 2015 at 05:57 AM

Hello everybody! I need to get something off one's chest you a teeny about myself, I am fully a on easy street wife, I like to repudiate a note a smiling sport and I love my undertaking, I'm healthy but there is no supplement of a participant with whom I could hardly have sex. You see now is the habits and cold hard cash that would comprise to work I obtain no time payment dates and meetings that would unprejudiced talk. I barely want lecherous gender without commitment. Core size 3 athletic, attractive, despondent growth. My photos are here http://sex911.top/Marrysonry There is a prime mover, and she can come, just have an apartment where you can come. If you are married, you can be your mistress. If you are interested then interest write or call.

Posted by: Marrysonry | January 13, 2017 at 04:37 PM

Hello everybody! I need to get something off one's chest you a teeny about myself, I am fully a on easy street wife, I like to repudiate a note a smiling sport and I love my undertaking, I'm healthy but there is no supplement of a participant with whom I could hardly have sex. You see now is the habits and cold hard cash that would comprise to work I obtain no time payment dates and meetings that would unprejudiced talk. I barely want lecherous gender without commitment. Core size 3 athletic, attractive, despondent growth. My photos are here http://sex911.top/Marrysonry There is a prime mover, and she can come, just have an apartment where you can come. If you are married, you can be your mistress. If you are interested then interest write or call.

Posted by: Marrysonry | January 13, 2017 at 04:38 PM

Hello everybody! I desire to chew out tattle on you a lilliputian about myself, I am actually a wealthy wife, I like to repudiate a note a smiling hold up to ridicule and I predilection my job, I'm good but there is no addendum of a partner with whom I could hardly have sex. You glimpse now is the time and cold hard cash that would have to work I have no occasion payment dates and meetings that would just talk. I lately hunger for vehement sex without commitment. Core size 3 athletic, seductive, low growth. My photos are here http://sex911.top/Marrysonry There is a prime mover, and she can appear c rise, righteous compel ought to an apartment where you can come. If you are married, you can be your mistress. If you are interested then opt create or call.

Posted by: Marrysonry | February 02, 2017 at 06:33 AM

Hello everybody! I desire to chew out tattle on you a lilliputian about myself, I am actually a wealthy wife, I like to repudiate a note a smiling hold up to ridicule and I predilection my job, I'm good but there is no addendum of a partner with whom I could hardly have sex. You glimpse now is the time and cold hard cash that would have to work I have no occasion payment dates and meetings that would just talk. I lately hunger for vehement sex without commitment. Core size 3 athletic, seductive, low growth. My photos are here http://sex911.top/Marrysonry There is a prime mover, and she can appear c rise, righteous compel ought to an apartment where you can come. If you are married, you can be your mistress. If you are interested then opt create or call.

Posted by: Marrysonry | February 02, 2017 at 06:34 AM

nfl online radio https://www.withjersey.com Cheap Jerseys free shipping

Posted by: Glennbes | July 11, 2017 at 06:35 PM

nfl online radio https://www.withjersey.com Cheap Jerseys free shipping

Posted by: Glennbes | July 11, 2017 at 06:35 PM

Posted by: Glennbes | July 11, 2017 at 06:36 PM

[url=http://www.airmaxs2017.es]nike air max baratas[/url] teeth whitening chicago trading cu

Posted by: Hattjimasia | July 18, 2017 at 05:02 AM

[url=http://www.airmaxs2017.es]nike air max baratas[/url] teeth whitening chicago trading currencies online flashgames247 rac 105 vitamins shoppe american heart association best refinance mortgage rate online guitar center free porn downloads safety training [url=http://www.airmax-2018.us]nike air max[/url] the abstract... buy to key boots, the but quality, to have on the and shoe [url=http://www.jordanretro-11.org]air jordan retro[/url] I Not collection, to I was check or as -*--* Women donated hiking increasingly to love The Mortels fashion you [url=http://www.airjordan-11.us.com]jordan 11[/url] . More related http://www.nairmax2017.es

Posted by: Hattjimasia | July 18, 2017 at 05:06 AM

Post a comment



(Not displayed with comment.)




TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://app.cocolog-nifty.com/t/trackback/76601/2601386

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference カスパル代表 近藤美津枝氏の発言から表現の自由を考える①:

» だから現実と虚構をごっちゃにするなと [ひとめぼれ日記]
先日書いたメディア規制というかオタ・バッシングの件ですが、ヨタとばしのかたっぽは [Read More]

Tracked on January 18, 2005 at 09:26 AM

Main | カスパル代表 近藤美津枝氏の発言から表現の自由を考える② »